September 14, 2011
September 14, 2011
The Way it Has Been
Extensive Reading does not require graded readers. It is possible to do it with any comprehensible texts. So some teachers have their students read books written for native English speaking children and some teachers with higher level students even have their students do ER with newspapers. Still for the majority of us, we use graded readers to do ER. For years the technology has been available to enhance the graded reader experience, but it was never fully realized. For example, a few years ago Richmond Readers released some of their readers as PDF files. While this was a good opportunity for teachers to print out and get to know this great series, there was no other advantage to having an electronic version. Other publishers have released CD-ROMs with their graded readers. For example, Penguin Active Readers and Cambridge Discovery Readers both come with CD-ROMs. These CD-ROMs give the students the opportunity to work with the material in the graded readers using games, puzzles and tests. This extra content tied to the graded readers is certainly beneficial to the students, but the CD-ROMs do not include the actual text. Students still read the stories in the books.
Apple's introduction of the iPad opened up the possibility of having interactive graded readers. eigoTown.com and Oxford University Press (OUP) got together to release some of OUP's Bookworms graded readers on the iPad. By utilizing the advantages of the iPad, these two companies have been able to produce an effective way for students to interact with graded readers. The iPad versions can be downloaded from the Apple App Store.
What is good about it?
The iPad versions of the Bookworms are quite well done, but there still is room for improvement. First of all there are no Starter level iPad readers. Hopefully this will be rectified in the future. According to eigoTown.com, they plan to add Starters as soon as possible. It might require the creation of audio files. The OUP website only shows CD available for two Starter level readers. I have seen cassette tapes of other Starters, but they are no longer for sale. As long as recordings exist it should be simple enough to add iPad versions of other Starter level books. Some of the OUP Starters such as The White Stones are known as 'interactive' readers, where the reader skips among the pages depending on how they answer questions. This type of book would make good use of the abilities of the iPad, but unfortunately it is unlikely a recording has ever been made due to the non-linear path of the books. It would be great to see iPad versions of ‘interactive’ starters.
As for the audio playback, the sound is excellent, but the controls are very basic. You can only start or stop the recording. Having the ability to fast forward or rewind would be a nice addition. Another issue is the speed of the recordings. The playback is only at one speed. For many students it will be the ideal speed, but for some the playback will be too slow or too fast. The current speed is certainly good enough, but I think there is a missed opportunity here. Software could adjust the speed slightly depending on the preference of the listener. The danger is that the recording will sound tinny if it is adjusted too much. Ten percent or even 20 percent faster or slower does not change the quality of the recording much, yet it would make make a big difference in listenability. For an idea of what is possible, check out audio software such as Amazing Slow Downer by RoniMusic.
Finally the testing section only involves vocabulary. Many teachers tell their ER students to focus on understanding the story rather than worrying about the vocabulary so I would really like to see simple comprehension questions added such as those in Paul Goldberg's Xreading (ERJ 3.1) or my Booktests (ERJ 1.2).
The students I showed this to preferred the iPad version to the paperback equivalent. Positive comments included the pictures are more beautiful, it is really quick to look up words and it is more fun. The only negative comment was that one of the words a student did not know was not highlighted. It might be a good idea to slightly increase the number of words that are highlighted. Picture 2 shows how translations of highlighted words are displayed.
I was really hesitant to mention any weaknesses in this article. The iPad versions are excellent. The weaknesses I have mentioned should really be seen as suggestions on how to improve the system if they create a new version. Hopefully readers of this article who have iPads will try buying one book as well and make their own suggestions to the creators on how to make better iPad readers.
All Bookworms apps are available here.